Jonathan M. Powell University of Central Florida
  • Home
  • Research
  • Coup d'etat Dataset

More thoughts post-coup/revolt democratization

5/29/2014

Comments

 
I wanted to post more data relevant the recent post at Monkey Cage.  That post only advertises the post-Cold War period and only uses one democracy indicator to illustrate what happens after revolts or coups, so I wanted to offer a more comprehensive look.  This can partially be seen as an extension of a recent post by Andrea Kendall-Taylor and Erica Frantz.

These figures show what happens after revolts (called "revolutions" here because I was apparently zoning out while making the figures) and coups when looking at different specifications of democracy.  Here I use Boix, Miller, & Rosato, Geddes, Wright, & Frantz, Cheibub, Gandhi, & Vreeland, and Polity (>+5) to determine if a state is a democracy.  Coup & revolt data come from Svolik (with coding updates from Erica Frantz).

DISCLAIMER: I am not suggesting that these countries are democratizing because of a coup or revolt.  In many cases a state might democratize in spite of an otherwise adverse event and in other cases "democratizing" might be nothing more than returning to the state of affairs prior to the coup/revolt.  If/when Thailand returns to democracy for example, it would be quite a stretch to say the coup led to democracy.

Full Sample

Here I'll just point to the major point I wanted to get at, which is underplayed in the Monkey Cage piece: democratization seems to follow revolts quickly or not at all; democratization can follow coups, though at a slower rate.  It is helpful to look at a wider timeframe.
Picture

Cold War (to 1991)

I didn't expect to see this, but those quickly-born democracies that follow revolts seem to have been very fragile during the Cold War.  Coups, meanwhile, continue to show a slow trend toward democracy (though at about half the rate seen in the post-Cold War.
Picture

Post-Cold War (since 1991)

This is what stayed in the Monkey Cage post.  Over 50% of post-revolt countries are democracies 5 years on, while this is true for around 35-40% of countries following coups.
Picture
Comments
comments powered by Disqus

    RSS Feed

    Jonathan Powell

    Associate Professor,
    Dept. of Political Science,
    University of Central Florida

    Blogs
    African Arguments
    Africa is a Country
    Democracy in Africa
    Duck of Minerva
    Lawyers, Guns, & Money
    Monkey Cage
    War on the Rocks

    Archives

    August 2019
    July 2019
    February 2015
    September 2014
    May 2014
    February 2014
    September 2013
    July 2013